Imagine stepping into the spotlight of a beloved dance competition as its top judge, only to confess that it's both thrilling and terrifying—Oti Mabuse is doing just that, and her story might change how you view reality TV judging forever. But here's where it gets really intriguing: Will her promise to 'just be honest' shake up the world of Dancing with the Stars, or is there a hidden art to softening the truth for the sake of entertainment?
Oti Mabuse, the fresh face taking over as head judge on Dancing with the Stars, opened up about her exciting yet daunting new chapter during Friday night's Late Late Show Christmas Special. This isn't just any talent show; it's Ireland's version of the globally popular format where celebrities team up with professional dancers to dazzle audiences, and Oti, a double winner from Britain's Strictly Come Dancing, is replacing Loraine Barry in the hot seat. The ninth season kicks off on RTÉ One and RTÉ Player on January 4, with returning judges Brian Redmond, Arthur Gourounlian, and Karen Byrne by her side. Oti described the experience so far as a mix of fear and joy, saying it's been 'so scary' but 'so much fun'—a relatable admission for anyone who's ever faced a big career leap.
The chemistry among the judges seems promising. Oti shared how they've already bonded over dinner, where she and Brian Redmond playfully tease each other relentlessly. 'We just like to go at it, we literally just make fun of each other,' she chuckled, painting a picture of a lively, supportive group dynamic that could make for some entertaining on-screen moments.
Host Patrick Kielty turned the chat to Oti's adjustment to life in Ireland, and her responses gave us a charming glimpse into her culture shock. 'It's very cold—I don't know how you guys do it; you are strong!' she exclaimed, highlighting how the chilly Irish weather is a stark contrast to her South African roots. To blend in, she dove right into local traditions: her first Guinness was a must-try, and she had an adorable anecdote about Taytos—those iconic Irish crisps. When co-host Laura Fox offered them with a look of pure horror at Oti's initial refusal, insisting they're a cultural staple, Oti gave in and now loves them. It's a simple example of how small gestures can bridge differences, making newcomers feel at home.
What stood out even more was Oti's take on Irish friendliness. 'What I've discovered is that Irish people love to get to know you,' she said. Patrick Kielty quipped that it's 'nosy dressed up as friendly,' and Oti agreed, recalling Brian's advice to just relax and embrace the inquiries. 'It's a lot of talking! But it's very nice, people generally are like 'Hi, welcome to Ireland, we want to get to know you,'' she explained. This warmth, she noted, comes with plenty of chatter, which might be overwhelming for some but feels welcoming overall.
And this is the part most people miss in talent show interviews: Oti's stance on judging. When asked if she'd soften her critiques given her dance background, she was firm—no way. 'No! Shows like Dancing with the Stars—it is for the people. And the people at home are not dumb, they want what they see to be reflected. Say what you see, just be honest with it,' she declared. For beginners wondering about the show's format, think of it as a competition where judges score performances based on technique, chemistry, and showmanship, and Oti's philosophy suggests prioritizing authenticity over sugarcoating. But here's where it gets controversial—should judges always lay it all out, even if it crushes a contestant's spirit? Some might argue that a bit of kindness builds confidence, while others, like Oti, believe viewers deserve unfiltered truth to keep the show real. It's a debate that could divide fans: Is brutal honesty the mark of a great judge, or does it risk turning entertainment into something too harsh?
The episode also unveiled the latest stars joining the lineup for 2026: musician Tolü Makay, Olympic rower Philip Doyle, and podcaster Amber Wilson. Oti had some wise counsel for them, urging them to dive in fully. 'Really embrace the whole thing, you only get one chance to do it,' she advised. And here's a pro tip for aspiring dancers or anyone facing a challenge: If doubts creep in—if you think, 'I can't do it, my body can't do it'—shut them down. Push past that mental block, because your body might surprise you with hidden strength and stamina. Once you overcome that hurdle, it transforms into an unforgettable, empowering journey. It's a lesson that extends beyond the dance floor, showing how mental shifts can unlock physical potential.
Catch The Late Late Show every Friday at 9:35pm on RTÉ One and RTÉ Player. What do you think—do you agree with Oti's honest approach to judging, or should talent shows lean more towards encouragement? Is there a risk that too much truth hurts the fun? Share your thoughts in the comments below; I'd love to hear your take!
